|
Post by DollyFinn on Aug 16, 2008 21:13:49 GMT
Well done the Town! A quick trawl through the Wessex teams results in the FA Cup preliminaries shows this is not a walkover league though. www.tonykempster.co.uk/facep.htm
|
|
|
Post by m3dolphin on Aug 16, 2008 21:39:25 GMT
Funny you should bring this up, I've given this some thought over the last few months. I'm of the mind the top six in the Wessex Premier could more than hold their own in the league above, even two leagues above. In fact I would even argue after watching some conference National and Conference South games (up to two a week) over the last few seasons that if the top six in the WP were to meet the bottom six in the Connie South the WP sides would have a good chance of coming out on top.
I took in the North Hants final back in May, Fleet Town v Tadley Calleva which TC , who won the Wessex Div1 title, won 1-0. Fleet finished as runners up in the BGB South West behind Farnborough, who were also beaten convincingly by Fleet only weeks earlier 3-0. I Notice that newly promoted AFC Totton got off to a good start today, beating AFC Hayes at home 6-0. I also watched a recent freindly between Thatcham Town (BGB SW) v Basingstoke Town (Con South), which the lower league team won 1-0, and they were quite convincing in the middle of the park. Without being Biased I find TK's tactics much more entertaining than any of the other managers I've watched and when Poole are really on top of their game It's a joy to watch.
|
|
|
Post by Bay Dolphin on Aug 17, 2008 10:47:02 GMT
Thanks Dolly. I agree with both you and with m3's experience of the quality of WP sides. The problem is in these circumstances and with only ONE team certain of going up from WP - and that subject to ground grading - is that is very difficult indeed to secure promotion. Maybe there should be play-offs from Step 5 as there are in the Steps above that. For example, top teams from all Step 4 leagues go up automatically and runners-up play-off for any residual places. Or increase the numbers coming down from Step 4. There certainly doesn't seem to be much between Step 5 and Step 4 - or even a lot higher, as you show m3.
|
|
|
Post by Bay Dolphin on Aug 17, 2008 21:11:57 GMT
Do you think that the influx of foreign players into the 'League of Greed' (Premiership), Championship and so on has made more quality indiginous players available lower down throughout the system and that this may be contributing to an overall improvement in non-league football generally?
|
|
|
Post by m3dolphin on Aug 18, 2008 13:35:13 GMT
I feel that's a very valid point Brian, and one that may have more of an effect than we think, although I'm not complaining as we now have more skilled local youngsters through the Non league levels. Another thing that stands out in the Non league pyramid are the two bottle necks that are created with teams trying to leave our level to get to level four. And the second bottle neck is level three to level two.
Perhaps this is why there seems to be two extremes in our league of either very good sides or very poor sides, and once a team wins promotion they have a very good chance of back to back promotions. This is further emphasised in teams winning promotion to level two ( Connie South ) and going on to mount a serious challenge to gain promotion to the Connie National, like Salisbury or Lewes. Braintree and Hampton also made the play offs in their first seasons in the CS. Is it any surprise that last years promoted sides to the CS find themselves in the top four or that AFC Totton got off to a sterling start with a 6-0 route ?
My feeling is, maybe there needs to be a look at how more than one team per league can be promoted from level 5 to try to aid the stronger teams with the better players to progress. As with the knock on effect with foreign players local youngsters are now finding themselves at the 'bigger', or 'well positioned', or 'best networked' non league clubs like Poole, Moneyfields, Wimborne, VTFC, Brockenhurst and Fareham. With no disrespect to other clubs who don't have the above credentials maybe more teams promoted from level five and more teams relegated from level four will help the cream players rise to the top and help all the leagues become more closely competitive ? Just some thoughts.
|
|
asif
Dolphin Forum Junior Member
Posts: 84
|
Post by asif on Aug 18, 2008 21:55:47 GMT
Just to bring a few facts to bear in the Wessex v BGS&W quality debate, in 2007-08 recently promoted teams from the Wessex League finished as follows: Gosport 11th, Thatcham 15th, Winchester 17th, Andover 19th. Hardly setting the world alight I think
|
|
|
Post by Bay Dolphin on Aug 19, 2008 8:38:20 GMT
Good point asif but it doesn't change the fact that it is very hard to get promoted from Step 5 with ground grading, several decent sides in most Step 5 leagues in with a shout and only one team certain to go up from each.
|
|
|
Post by m3dolphin on Aug 19, 2008 8:40:04 GMT
Just to bring a few facts to bear in the Wessex v BGS&W quality debate, in 2007-08 recently promoted teams from the Wessex League finished as follows: Gosport 11th, Thatcham 15th, Winchester 17th, Andover 19th. Hardly setting the world alight I think Thanks for wising me up Asif, with those facts it seems maybe the bottle neck situation higher up doesn't mirror the one lower down. I was still amazed at the even game in the NH final between a Wessex div1 side and one from the BGBSW.
|
|
|
Post by crashtest1976 on Aug 19, 2008 12:22:10 GMT
I have argued this one many times before. People have to accept the Wessex league for what it is - a league which is the border between clubs which have a budget and clubs which don't - hence the undoubted '2 leagues within 1' that exists in the wessex. This is not, if it is accepted, a problem. Every club has the right to be ambitious and get out of the league, just as every club has the right to maintain a purely amateur status and attempt to stay in the league.
What has to be remembered is that many of the sides that have been mentioned are not necessarily as stable as PTFC. Brockenhurst, for example, were a bottom 5 team not too many years ago! Yes, I believe there should be more than one up - possibly 2. However to make anymore would be a misjudgement. As asif has said, no-one has really gone through the leagues since Eastleigh and it would reflect badly on the Wessex if too many clubs were to be promoted only for them to come back down.
The league is a good one - every league has clubs which are seen a 'poor' (Derby with 11 points springs to mind) but we should accept those clubs and at the end of the season if they weren't good enough they'll go down and someone'll come up to give it a go.
|
|
|
Post by m3dolphin on Aug 19, 2008 15:52:06 GMT
Good post crashtest. I have a lot to learn about football at this level.
|
|
|
Post by slepe12 on Aug 21, 2008 17:24:35 GMT
Good post crashtest................I have to say the quality of discussion in this forum is very high. Yet another good example of our claim to have the best web-site in the league.
|
|
|
Post by expat on Aug 21, 2008 20:11:52 GMT
.......and its read in some very far off places. Thanks everybodyfor keeping us armchair fans right in the thick of things. Winning the league and a good cup run will generate a lot of interest in the club..even the Branksome plan has put PTFC on a lot of peoples minds... UP THE TOWN!!
|
|
|
Post by slepe12 on Aug 22, 2008 17:35:03 GMT
.......and its read in some very far off places. Thanks everybodyfor keeping us armchair fans right in the thick of things. Winning the league and a good cup run will generate a lot of interest in the club..even the Branksome plan has put PTFC on a lot of peoples minds... UP THE TOWN!! No worries mate, I could talk all day about the Dolphins ;D
|
|